Mary S. Nash
104 S. Houston Street
Kaufman , Texas   75142
NashHulme@msn.com

www.KaufmanZoning.net

972-962-7706
May 18, 2003  

Mr. Henry Tatum
Dallas Morning News
P. O. Box 655237
Dallas , Tx 75265-5237  

Re:  Bloody Betty Brown deserves the Dallas News Thumbs Down award  

Dear Hank:  

Norma Minnis said I should send you this letter.  

I would like to nominate my State Representative Betty Brown for the Dallas News “thumbs down” award.  

Bloody Betty Brown (R-Terrell), is the primary sponsor of the Texas Live Horse Slaughter Bill, HB 1324, which would de-criminalize the illegal activities of Texas’s two live horse slaughter plants, Beltex in Fort Worth, and Dallas Crown in Kaufman where young, healthy horses are stunned with bolts through their brains, strung up by one hind leg, and have their throats slit so their beating hearts can pump the blood from their bodies.  This process is mandated by the United States Department of Agriculture for slaughter of animals intended for human consumption.  Then they cut off their legs and heads, which I am told are sold to zoos, and the horses’ torsos are frozen and shipped overseas out of DFW Airport .  Belgium is the biggest importer of U.S. horsemeat for human consumption, and France is next.  Belgium-Luxembourg $19.15 million, France $7.86 million, according to Fort Worth Star Telegram, 9/26/02 . 

Meanwhile, from our little 40 acre farm next to Dallas Crown, I see beautiful, fat, young Arabians, Quarterhorses, and Dunns waiting for slaughter, like the ones in this photo taken at Dallas Crown on Sep 1, 2002.  

On Aug 7, 2002, Texas Attorney General John Cornyn issued an opinion letter saying it is a crime to sell, possess, or transport horse meat for human consumption, even if the consumption takes place outside the U.S.  See text of opinion letter at   http://www.oag.state.tx.us/opinopen/opinions/op49cornyn/jc-0539.htm.  The only two live horse slaughter plants in the United States , Beltex in Fort Worth and Dallas Crown in Kaufman, filed suit in federal court on Sep 26, 2002 to stop Tarrant County DA Tim Curry and Kaufman County DA Bill Conradt from prosecuting.  See text of lawsuit at http://kaufmanzoning.net/horsemeat/Complaint%20(No.%204-02CV0804-A)-WORD.doc.  

On Feb 26, 2003 my State Representative, Bloody Betty Brown, responded to all this by filing HB 1324 which would grant legal status to the only two remaining live horse slaughter plants in the United States of America.  

Bloody Betty Brown made a statement at the Ag Committee hearing on March 25 that Texas needs live horse slaughter because we have so many old and crippled horses.  She obviously had not read page 3 of “Plaintiffs’ Motion for Temporary Injunction”, Beltex & Dallas Crown vs. Tim Curry & Bill Conradt, which says that 90% of the horses slaughtered at the two Texas live horse slaughter plants come from outside Texas .  See text of Motion at http://kaufmanzoning.net/horsemeat/bmti.pdf.  

Bloody Betty also said that the Texas & Southwestern Cattle Raisers Association guard against stolen horses being slaughtered because they have brand inspectors at the two plants who “check each horse.”  What Ms. Brown forgot to find out is whether or not the two brand inspectors have actually found any stolen horses.

In an April 11 email message to me, TSCRA Director Todd McCartney wrote,  

2)  The # of horses reported stolen to TSCRA is not a figure I can get my hands on easily.   It is not a figure we use, so it is not an item totaled in our database.  It could be discovered but only by man hours reading summary reports submitted by each one of our 31 officers.  

3)  As I mentioned to you on the phone, we do know the # of horses recovered by TSCRA law officers ...but not the location of their recovery.  In the last 10 years (1992-2002) we recovered 1,024 stolen horses.  Since we started inspecting horses at the two plants we have recovered 837.  However, we can't pull up how many of those were apprehended at the plants. Again, that would take man hours to discover. It is simply not a number that is totaled.  

See  http://kaufmanzoning.net/horsemeat/McCartneytoNash1.htm
 

State Representative Charlie Howard (R-Sugarland) had his horses stolen, and he says they ended up being slaughtered.  It made him mad, so in 1997 he supported legislation that mandates $3 for every horse slaughtered in Texas will go to the Texas & Southwestern Cattle Raisers Association for their program to make sure stolen horses don’t get slaughtered.  I wonder if Rep Howard ever followed up to see if the TSCRA has found any stolen horses at the Texas live horse slaughter plants with all that money they’ve been collecting.  I bet not.  The same 1997 legislation mandates that $2 for each slaughtered horse goes to the Texas Agricultural Extension Service (Texas A&M) to teach horse owners how to keep their ponies from being stolen.  Anyone checking to see how that money is being spent?  I bet not.  Meanwhile, Todd McCartney says the number of horses slaughtered in Texas is on the rise.   

total  number of horses slaughtered in recent years at the two plants is:
        2000    35,630
        2001    38,750
        2002    40,336
 

No wonder the Texas & Southwestern Cattle Raisers Association sent Zach Brady to testify in favor of Bloody Betty’s HB 1324 before the House Ag Committee on March 25.  And veterinarian Steve Hicks of Palestine said he had a letter from Dr. Ted Friend, Texas A&M, saying he is in favor of live horse slaughter too.  Money works wonders on attitudes toward live horse slaughter in Texas .  

Bloody Betty laments that jobs would be lost and economies spoiled if the plants closed.  At the Dallas Crown plant site they slaughtered cattle before they slaughtered horses, and they could do that again.  I understand that Beltex slaughters other animals besides horses, and they could slaughter cattle too.  

Lots of folks have speculated that Bloody Betty is receiving some benefit from the $40 million a year Belgian/French Texas live horse slaughter business that supplies horsemeat to Europe and Asia , where the meat is sold for up to $15 a pound.  Other than her campaign contributions from the Texas & Southwestern Cattle Raisers Association, the Texas Quarterhorse Association and the Texas Veterinarian PAC, I have no evidence that Bloody Betty is being rewarded for her involvement in Texas live horse slaughter.  I don’t think she’s on the take, I just think she’s stupid.  

On April 23 I sat in the visitors’ gallery of the Texas House of Representatives while Bloody Betty’s Republican friends lined up at the east podium to feed her fodder while she blathered on about the virtues of live horse slaughter.  I could not believe my ears when I first heard the canned sound of a horse’s whinny.  Then I heard it again….and again.  There were lots of snickers and laughter, especially from Fred Brown (R-College Station).  I was embarrassed to be a Texan, but proud to be a Democrat.  Sixty Republicans voted in favor of HB 1324; 19 voted against it.   Twenty-one Democrats voted in favor; 36 voted no.  

Steve Wolens (D-Dallas) and Toby Goodman (R-Arlington) gallantly tried to stop HB 1324 on the floor of the Texas House of Representatives on April 23, 2003, and former Speaker Pete Laney (D-Hale Center) voted against HB 1324 in the House Ag Committee.  

Bloody Betty Brown’s live horse slaughter bill, HB 1324, now awaits action by the Senate Ag subcommittee.  

The 40 acre farm next to Dallas Crown in Kaufman has been in my family for 150 years.  I see the horses unloading from double decker cattle haulers, and I see them milling around in their holding pens.  When the wind is from the west and I’m standing in my backyard in Kaufman, I smell the stench of 150 dead horses.  

Enclosed is a list of the killer-buyers who supply horses to Dallas Crown.  

Sincerely,  

Mary S. Nash
Encl.
      Dallas Crown Killer-Buyers